AfterDawn Forums
These messages are comments to this news item:

L.A. anti-piracy task force seizes $4.06 million in pirated goods

news article released on:

Los Angeles' very own anti-piracy task force, under Operation Chimney Sweep, has arrested 10 people and seized over $4 million worth of pirated movies, music and counterfeit apparel. L.A. city controller Wendy Greuel says the arrest and raids took place all throughout L.A. by "dozens of officers." A number of trade group executives including Larry Hahn of the MPAA and Marcus Cohen ...

Read full article

This discussion thread has 24 messages.

#1
Shouldn't the L.A. Anti-Piracy Task Force be cruising the coastline, on the lookout for Blackbeard and his ilk?

Meanwhile, how's that Mexican cartel border war workin' out for you all? No more cartel in East L.A.?

I guess it's nice to be able to choose your fights. That way you've less a chance of showing your ineptitude.

Quote me as saying I was mis-quoted. - Groucho Marx
▼▼ This topic has 23 answers - they are below this advertisement ▼▼
AfterDawn Advertisement
#2
This is beginning to get ridiculous...... Why the bloody hell is our Police more worried on fighting"Movie/Music Pirates" then catching the real criminals plus Hollywood is the true criminals trying to force our copyright system and ideals in other countries
#3
The RIAA, MPAA, or some other such organization probably paid for these officers...there is no way that an overburdened department like that of the LA Police would waste manpower on this.
#4
If these people were selling pirated content for personal gain I have no sympathy for them. However if they were simply downloaders or uploaders then it's a crock of shit. The article is a bit vague on exactly which is the case here but the title implies the former.
#5
I'm thinking the former as well. In which case I say job well done.
#6
Originally posted by hikaricor:
If these people were selling pirated content for personal gain I have no sympathy for them. However if they were simply downloaders or uploaders then it's a crock of shit. The article is a bit vague on exactly which is the case here but the title implies the former.
I agree with you completely. If the group of people had counterfeit electronics (i.e. iPods, DSis, etc.) then they deserve to be caught. Same thing goes if they were selling pirated materials such games and movies.

"The only people who should buy Monster cable are people who light cigars with Benjamins." - Gizmodo
#7
I'm so relieved these mastermind criminals are finally caught and will be brought to justice! I'll sleep better tonight knowing that only serial killers, rapists, armed robbers, drug dealers, and the like are still roaming the streets. At least they aren't pirating movies, music, etc.!

"Do not underestimate the power of an enemy, no matter how great or small, to rise against you another day." - Atilla
#8
I don't care about people sharing & downloading, to me that is not 'pirating'.....and as the industry's current at or near record profit levels show doesn't actually hurt anyone.

However, people who make physical copies of other people's work to sell on deserve everything they get.
Especially those low-lifes that pirate things like car & motorcycle brake pads and flog supposedly brand-name stuff which is shoddy & downright dangerous.

I have to agree on the priority thing tho, since when did anyone amongst the general public ever ask their national Police or the local law enforcement to waste their limited resources on this sort of stuff.
This message has been edited since its posting. Latest edit was made on 24 Dec 2010 @ 14:51
#9
I think you can dedicate adequate resources to more than one aspect of law enforcement. The argument that serial killers are roaming free because some counterfeiters were arrested is a false dichotomy.
#10
Originally posted by Azuran:
I think you can dedicate adequate resources to more than one aspect of law enforcement. The argument that serial killers are roaming free because some counterfeiters were arrested is a false dichotomy.
Give me a break! The statement wasn't meant to be that serious, it was to drive a point home that law enforcement has better things to do with taxpayer's money. I guess you couldn't figure that out.
#11
Really? I completely disagree. I think law enforcement protecting property rights is an essential use of our taxes. But because it's the property of a corporation the situation has less clout? You give me a break.
#12
Originally posted by Semperfipal:
I'm so relieved these mastermind criminals are finally caught and will be brought to justice! I'll sleep better tonight knowing that only serial killers, rapists, armed robbers, drug dealers, and the like are still roaming the streets. At least they aren't pirating movies, music, etc.!
LMAO!
#13
We Know Better Unverified new user
Denying the homeless a chance to support themselves...is that what the left wing nuts really want? As mentioned above, the CA cops don't want to risk their fat life time pensions chasing the real crimes of the illegals & drug cartels.
#14
The Swap Meet gonna go bankrupt, dayum
This message has been edited since its posting. Latest edit was made on 25 Dec 2010 @ 5:39

True thug Afterdawn memeber since 05! Shout out to all those old school member still in the ranks of Newbie! Represent!
#15
Originally posted by Azuran:
Really? I completely disagree. I think law enforcement protecting property rights is an essential use of our taxes. But because it's the property of a corporation the situation has less clout? You give me a break.
You sound like a corporate attorney, but I'll give you a break! Merry Xmas! But I still think it's a waste of government resources.
#16
I personally do feel, also, that there are many more important things for local and federal law enforcement to focus on. Leave the intellectual property stuff for civil lawyers. After all, I can't call a cop when Sony bricks my PS3 cuz I modified it.....or can I.....
#17
so i guess all is well in the world when the biggest threat in the U.S. is pirated movies music and games. for a second there i thought we had to worry about the douches in north korea and the war in iraq thast been goin on for goin on 8 years. lets not forget the ever popular "war on drugs" the same war that you see even some of the politicians that are fighting it snort it up themselves. but yes we have those "dangerous" movie pirates off the street. i dont know about the most of you but where im from movies aint cheap like they use to be and getting a bootleg here and there actually saved me a couple of bucks. the question really is who are the REAL criminals? could it be the entertainment industry. it amuses me that the economy is alwasy the focus when there is a bust. do they ever ask why the people that are selling them why? could it be times are tough for them too and this is the only way to make a quick buck? which is worst selling pirated movies or selling drugs out on the street? just a thought...
#18
In the UK copyright breach is a civil offense, not a criminal one.

Selling shoddy dangerous goods (like counterfeit brake pads) as if they fully comply to the necessary minimum standards would be a criminal offense.

Basically bundling in the sharing of music or films on-line to that sort of thing is just window-dressing for the shallow of thinking.
A con.

Given that the overwhelming majority of sharing is for films & music from the already most well known and successful artists & studios it seems to me that going after sharers is not only a grotesque abuse of limited resources but in any event a proven case of an entirely ineffectual allocation of those limited resources.

There isn't a limitless amount of money for law enforcement and protecting the already most well off individuals and corporations who are not suffering in any credible way is ludicrous.

.....as are that industry's crazy ideas of copyright inperpetuity.
Talk about a threat to the creative process and a total refual to accept that all human progress is built on the shoulders of those that went before.
#19
Originally posted by Tristan_2:
This is beginning to get ridiculous...... Why the bloody hell is our Police more worried on fighting"Movie/Music Pirates" then catching the real criminals plus Hollywood is the true criminals trying to force our copyright system and ideals in other countries
They do what they are told. Obama would not have been elected had it not been for the early media finical support.
#20
shadyj Suspended due non-functional email address
Originally posted by Semperfipal:
Originally posted by Azuran:
Really? I completely disagree. I think law enforcement protecting property rights is an essential use of our taxes. But because it's the property of a corporation the situation has less clout? You give me a break.
You sound like a corporate attorney, but I'll give you a break! Merry Xmas! But I still think it's a waste of government resources.
He must be a corporate attorney or some other kind of "bad guy" since he doesn't share your viewpoint. What's the bad part of enforcing all the laws again?
#21
Crazycro Suspended due non-functional email address
I,ve heard this quite a bit lately...soon there will be upper class and lower class NO more middle class.

When it costs close to a hundred bucks for a family of 2 adults and 3 children to see a movie and buy a few treats at the local theatre... seriously do people really need any other reason to pirate or buy pirated stuff....?
#22
Originally posted by Crazycro:
I,ve heard this quite a bit lately...soon there will be upper class and lower class NO more middle class.

When it costs close to a hundred bucks for a family of 2 adults and 3 children to see a movie and buy a few treats at the local theatre... seriously do people really need any other reason to pirate or buy pirated stuff....?
I admit the cost of this stuff is ridiculous but that's because we STILL buy it. I go to the theaters a handful of times each year. If it gets more expensive, I don't go.

That's like the imposed 30 day DVD release windows on Netflix and Redbox. Does Hollywood really think I'll pay BlockBuster $5 to rent or outright buy the movie for $20-30? WRONG! I'll just wait 30 days, I already waited how many months for it to come to DVD.

My point: these are wants, not needs. Patience goes a long way.
#23
Crazycro Suspended due non-functional email address
Originally posted by SProdigy:
Originally posted by Crazycro:
I,ve heard this quite a bit lately...soon there will be upper class and lower class NO more middle class.

When it costs close to a hundred bucks for a family of 2 adults and 3 children to see a movie and buy a few treats at the local theatre... seriously do people really need any other reason to pirate or buy pirated stuff....?
I admit the cost of this stuff is ridiculous but that's because we STILL buy it. I go to the theaters a handful of times each year. If it gets more expensive, I don't go.

That's like the imposed 30 day DVD release windows on Netflix and Redbox. Does Hollywood really think I'll pay BlockBuster $5 to rent or outright buy the movie for $20-30? WRONG! I'll just wait 30 days, I already waited how many months for it to come to DVD.

My point: these are wants, not needs. Patience goes a long way.
Very true... I want my kids to see those movies...:)
#24
digiprop Unverified new user
The shame of this whole situation is the application of outdated business approaches and practices being forced onto something as promising as the Internet. The future is here and the problem is not us sharing but these companies looking for absolute control and free reign. The medium has become so fluid there is no possible way to control it. Sharing is not to be looked at as stealing but as a form of free advertising. Many people do show support when something good comes along despite the long shadow cast by antiquated bullying businesses crying foul for simple greed.
This discussion thread has been automatically closed, as it hasn't received any new posts during the last 180 days. This means that you can't post replies or new questions to this discussion thread.

If you have something to add to this topic, use this page to post your question or comments to a new discussion thread.