Banned Xbox Live Users Class Action Investigation (Submit Your Info)

Abington IP, a law firm specializing in consumer class actions posted this on their website.

*Update* They updated their text (also including HDD Crippling now. Still no diff made between GT and Console Bans however). Here's their new txt:

Full Story/Submit Form: abingtonlaw.com

Note: Who knows ... 1M banned users could make a difference. Spread the word!

Update: Figured I would edit this thread as it has been updated. A few members here may feel this is absolutely ridiculous BUT there are several others who feel MS did more damage than good in their attempts to combat piracy. In a crazy world, if a few thousand 360 users submit their info and MS caves in a little (re-activating HDD functionality) those of little interest will most likely jump on the bandwagon of the ridiculous ... I'm sure.

 

I think that those that had threads about spoofed, drives using unmodded firmware should maybe contact them as well. They wouls have an even stronger case. The only flaw in this one is that the suit is for unrefunded live fees.. they could still have a case though since there are many that may not be able to afford a new xbox right away..

 

I'm sure M$ have some pretty good lawyers and consulted them before the bannings. This is most likely some law firm trying to make a name for themselves and get some publicity. I don't see what M$ have done wrong with the timing of this ban wave. It's just good business.

 

I don't think these guys know what they're talking about, there's no case here.

 

retarded and second time this has been posted.

 

Sure they have some pretty good lawyers they consulted beforehand, the lawyers prolly advised them of the risks and as MS usually does, they took the risk and banned people without consideration..
Has the EU not proved that MS has shady illegal marketing tactics?

 

**Updated with new HDD disabling information** for those interested

 

I don't know guys kinda makes sense to me. with the courts today you never know

guess we will see

 

If they would only not cripple the hdd, that's all I care about. It's an extra kick in the nuts from MS .

 

LOL @ feeling like a victim after essentially stealing hundreds to thousands of dollars worth of software from Microsoft, developers and publishers. I had my console banned, and I feel sorry for anyone who knows they are at fault and are taking part in this. Take some responsibility for your actions.

 

Vigilante justice is not any more right just because your name is microsoft, they designed the system originally with cheap drives, we came up with a backup method that was abused but nonetheless a backup system for poor dvd drives....
They chose to take justice in their own hands...

 

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

That... may be... the dumbest thing I've ever...ever....ever, read in my entire life.

Reminds me of the woman that sued McDonalds when she spilled the coffee on herself.

 

Yeah but didn't she win Millions or something like that?

 

Poor example. People always go to that lawsuit like it is some kind of example of how absurd our legal system is. The truth behind that story is that the woman was given coffee that was about 30 degrees hotter than normal coffee. She spilled some on her lap (it casued burns) she only wanted McDonals to pay for the dry clean of her dress. McDonalds declined. She then sued for pain and suffering.

 

because the american system is flawed and the people here abuse it and are sue happy. it's even worse here in cali. people are too lazy today to make a buck so there lookin to get rich quick any way they can.

like everybody else has said in this thread... you should know the risk before you mod. take responsibility for your actions.

 

lol I agree about the its worse here in cali its sad when so many people sue over so much stuff its common place now.

 

Edit: why bother with all the +1 erzz that got banned and THINK THEY HAVE RIGHTS!!!

 

Forgive me, but you are an idiot. Not everyone who got banned pirated their games. I legitly own every backup I have.

 

I wouldn't say that there is no case.

Certainly, they can ban you for violation of the EULA. But I am not sure that they can brick your hard drive or read and relay information from your system that you have not given permission for.

"We may automatically check your version of the software. We may automatically download upgrades to the software to your computer or console to update, enhance, and further develop the Service."

"and that we have the right to send data , applications or other content to any software or hardware that you are using to access the Service for the express purpose of detecting an unauthorized modification."

This doesn't sound like they can brick your drive or corrupt information! In a legal battle, they might be made to reveal how they detect and transmit this information in order to prove that they have neither violated your privacy nor done anything illegal.

A lot can come from a lawsuit other than money.

 

Edit: Why bother deal with all the +1 erz and peeps that like to flame.