Dots in Bluray Playback

Hi, i need some advice, i have a bluray mkv file which i converted from bluray dvd. but when i play a bluray movie from the disc itself or from a mkv file, i always seem to get these gray dottish dots in playback have a look at the picture. they only seem to appear in dark scene well they become more clearer to see i think, i still see them in light scenes, does anyone know what it is and how to get rid of it.

image =

Also whats the best software to playback mkv bluray files, i currently use vlc.

thanks for your help

 

Well it could simply be film grain, which usually occurs more in dark (under lit) scenes. For older folks movies always had grain in darker scenes. Many older films being transferred to Blu-Ray are being processed to try to eliminate it to more suit today's customers who seem to prefer a shot on video look. A prime example is the movie Patton which looks nothing like the original I saw in the theaters. The removal of grain is not without some inherent problems as certain artifacts and loss of details can occur.

You could try Xvid4PSP to make your MKV. It has many options available that may mitigate the effect if you prefer. Look under Denoise/Sharpen.

Do some of the newer HD MKV conversions of recent movies floating around also exhibit this in VLC?

 

but i have the same problem on all my blu dvds, played in both pc and ps3, the ones im using are spiderman 3, babylon ad, transformer. i thought blu ray was spot on in detail and clearness, can you give me a picture of what yours look like to see if there the same

 

When you say ps3 what are you viewing them on?

These are VLC png snaps from mp4 rips. But again some filtering may have been used.

 

im view them either from ps3 to my hd tv, or from my pc to my hd tv, everything is hd connected. and u use the actual blue ray discs and still get the problem, i look at your pictures, and they seem crystal clear. nothing like mine.

here are more picture from vlc in the png format

 

I'm a little confused. What Blu-Ray drive are you using in your computer? I didn't think that VLC could play Blu-Ray?

 

im play the .mkv file with vlc, is there any other software which is better at playing blu ray. especially mkv?

some more info id

My HDTV is a LG M2294D 22inch HDTV it supports 1080p

my blu ray dvds that i have are Babylon A.D, The Dark Knight, Spiderman 3, Saints & Soldeirs, and Casino Royale.

they all have these small snowy dots on, when i play them on my ps3.

there has to be some way of fixing this porblem they alll cannot have this grain problem can they?

thanks for your help

 

Well VLC, MPC and I also have JetAudio Media Player (which I like more and more) all play my MKVs fine. VLC uses less cpu.

The only common denominator I see is your monitor. I would review all my settings. Can you take your ps3 to friends house and see how it looks a larger flatscreen?

Here's an Xvid conversion (AVI now) of the 2nd 1080p MKV sample. Same resolution but half the file size. Tried to get the same scene.



Still looks good at half the files size. The MKVs bitrate is 8511 Kbps the Xvid's is 4675 Kbps.

 

none of my friends have a hdtv, so cannot test it out that way. here a picture of iran man 1080p



it looks better than a 720p, anumated films i watch in hd seem amazing quality, maybe it is just the movie and i need a bigger screen to get the full potential, what size screen do you have?