DVD Shrink Issues

I know wrong forum but i'm desperate

Pretty self explainatory, when i backup my DVD's i'm faced with the problem of poor quality insert because they are printed on paper not the thin glossy sorta-like poster paper that is in all DVD inserts

I need specific type of paper so i know where to look, don't want matte = yuck, don't want glossy = too thick and hard to bend

Please help me, i'm sure you can buy it in reams of the stuff, it's logic guys