Sorry, wrong forum. Please ignore.

I bought a 360 about a year and a half ago and was going to mod it. I did open the 360 and connected it to the sata card I bought for my PC. But I could not get my PC to work with the sata card.

So I just bought a pre modded system and decided to sell the other one. I finally sold it to a guy at work for 150.

Two hours later he calls me and claims he is getting the open tray error! This system is brand new. I never used the console
other than to make sure it powered on after putting it back together. However, I don't think I ever played a game with it either

Plus, he knew I had already opened the case. So it would be the perfect opportunity to pull a switcheroo.

I find it a little hard to believe that a brand new system has a dead DVD drive. I think he probably brought it home and switched out a broken drive from another 360.

Is there any way to tell if the drive is the same one that was originally in the case?

Unless I can prove it, I'm going to have to give him his money back. Just because I'm not 100% certain he's lying.

If anybody has any ideas as far as how I can prove or disprove my theory, I would really appreciate it.

Thanks