Burning issues - Help needed so very confused

Morning everyone, I hope someone can give me some advice because this is bizarre.

I have two xbox consoles, one with hitachi, one with lite on both modded (altho lite-on not by me).
I have burnt backup copies that all work with the Hitachi but all give the error "disk dirty" part the way through the game and everytime you try to install to HD on the Lite-on "74850C".

Borrowed a backup off a friend of the same game i have, and bugger me it worked fine on the lite-on.

Im using verbs, but the backup disk that worked has an ID of "UMEDISC-DL1_64.

Can anyone shed any light on this,

Could it be the method of burning even if they work in the Hitachi ?

Could it be burner ?

Or is it the obvious disk , but i got the verbs ?

So confused anyone shed any light youll be a star.