Star Wars Episode 3 - what did you think of it ?

Not really, episodes I-III are from one generation and IV-VI are from the next. so they can be compared. Anyways, Lord of the Rings is really one big book/movie too, but I can say one is better than the other. Yes, the overall story is linked and most of the characters are the same, but you can say one is better than the other.

Not to mention, coming from your logic, any television show is just a continuation of the last episode too, but you can say one is better than the other.

 

Like Star Wars, i also see Lord of the Rings as one big movie. And even the Matrix trilogy.

Look at it this way. Each Star wars has something to bring to the table.
A New Hope establishes the universe and key characters.

Empire Strikes Back shows Luke becoming stronger and reveals new characters and reveals Darth Vaders identity

REturn of the Jedi concludes the series

Phantom Menace introduced the origins of Vader and some backstory of Obi-Wan.

Attack of the CLones shows anakin slowly going towards the dark side and falling in love with Padme.

Revenge of the Sith shows what pushes anakin over the edge and how he becomes Vader.

Now do you get it? All of them are completely different. The only thing that can determine whether you like it or not is action. But even then, action isn't always relevant to the story.

And the thing about tv shows. You can compare an episode to another episode. They aren't the same story. If there are two episodes, and the first one ends with "to be continued", it means that the next episode is following the same story line. How can you compare the story lines if they're following the same story?

Same thing with Star Wars. Its one huge story.

Now of they made a Knights of the Old Republic movie, then you can compare them becasue the two are totally different.

I'm done with my rant.haha

 

there is a story that says george lucas is a creature in the revenge movie

did any one spot the charector or alien he portrays i know his son
is in episode 2 as one of the young jedis in the jedi building and in episode 3 he is the last young jedi who batlles as balla organa is realizing the jedi's have been turned on--when he is leaving the building--the one jedi that fights the guards

but where was lucas

 

George lucas is playing Baron Papanoida. All i have is the name.
His daughter is in it too, Amanda Lucas.

 

There are newspapers that are stating that this movie is a political statement against George Bush and his administration and the war in Iraq, with Bush as the evil Palpatine. Although Lucas denies it and says he wrote the movie sometime ago.

http://www.usatoday.com/life/movies/news/2005-05-17-sith-politics_x.htm

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1405333/posts

 

Good film love me starwars

 

@wolfniggr:

to answer your question, both. Saw the workprint first and went to the theater to see it today and no, the timers didn't take much away from it and I find the quality to be pretty good (8.5 out of 10). Too bad it's full screen instead of widescreen.

George Lucas should have had an older guy play Anakin/Vader for this movie. Cristensen doesn't really fit the part of an ominous, powerful character and his transformation at the end is kind of corny. The way he comes off the stretcher like Frankenstein's monster with that wimpy groan when he learns of Padme's untimely *****.

 

out of the whole movie, the only thing i think they could of approved on was the grievous vs. obi-wan fight. He lost his sabers to quickly. And he could of done some more spectacular manuevers. Sort of like the clone wars cartoon. he did some pretty cool moves in there.

But the fight was still pretty sweet.

 

What is the first movie called? Not 4,5,6!

 

I just saw it and it was one of the best movies that I have seen this year. Way better than the last one.

 

The bit that made me laugh the most was General Grievous with a cough.
He's a bloody robot for crying out loud, how would he get a cough?

My electric toaster has never developed 'flu-like' symptoms, nor has my microwave ever suffered from a severe bout of hayfever.

Having said that my vacuum cleaner does sound like it has a chest infection. Where should I take it. Doctors? Electrical repair shop? Scrapyard? Mortuary?

 

[bold]DARKSIDE[/bold]

 

how do you get those pictures in each posts?

 

General Grievous was supposed to be part alien part machine.
He was a bit of insight into what anakin would become.

 

who saw the millenium falcon

 

B2D327, the workprint that you saw was pirated(stolen from lacasfilmLTD). And the person who set it up to distribute didn't bother to letterbox it and instead of cropping it to 4:3 he sqeezed the entire thing to 4:3 which made it look even more like shit. That and the fact that the timer was at the top of the film the entire time make this unwatchable.